Plastic Cookie Cutters For Sale At Grandma's House!

Plastic Cookie Cutters and Shapers
Go to METAL COOKIE CUTTERS Unless otherwise stated, we have one of each item

Cookie cutter collectors, come on in! I don't make cookies very often, but I enjoy the old cookie cutters. You can expect these cookie cutters and shapers to be previously owned, gently used, slightly discolored, and show normal signs of wear - you might even find a cookie crumb or two. I haven't spent a lot of time cleaning them up - they're pretty much like they were when they were still in Grandma's cupboard drawer.

6" x 10" white plastic cookie cutter makes 7 different cookies at once. Bear, pig, cat, bunny, elephant, duck, and squirrel.
$8.00, Item K371

7" x 12" red plastic cookie cutter makes 7 different cookies at once. Heart, bell, Christmas tree, reindeer, half moon, 6-pointed star, 5-pointed star, king, and angel.
Item K372

SOLD.

Wilton Santa's Cookie Sleigh Kit. 1983 Wilton Enterprises, Inc., Woodridge, IL. Instruction booklet included. Christmas.
SOLD.
Item K11

Set of 6 green Christmas Cookie Cutters, still in its original package. Santa, reindeer, star, tree, angel, and sleigh. Item #00451, Arrow Plastic Manufacturing Co.
$15.00, Item K378

Set of 5 green cookie cutters, 1984. Wilton Cookie Maker Holiday Shapes Cookie Cutter Set. 6½" Christmas tree, 4" gingerbread boy, 4" gingerbread girl, 6" clown, and 4½" angel. Stock No. 2304-105 No. 1821-105., still in its original package.
$15.00, Item K374

Jell-o Jigglers Alphabet, 1991. Letters are 2" tall.
Item K14

SOLD.

Jell-o Jigglers Alphabet, 1991. Letters are 2" tall. New in unopened package.
Item K12

SOLD.

Set of 5 Jell-o Jigglers animals, still in their original package. Giraffe, elephant, alligator, lion, and bear.
Item K375

SOLD.

Set of 4 Jello Jigglers animals. Elephant, bear, lion, and alligator. Alligator is almost 4" long.
$8.00, Item K293

Blue Snoopy, United Feature Syndicate, Inc, 3½".
$18.00, Item K397

Red Charlie Brown, United Feature Syndicate, Inc, 3½".
$18.00, Item K398

Green Lucy, United Feature Syndicate, Inc, 3½".
$18.00, Item K399

White Linus, United Feature Syndicate, Inc, 3½".
$18.00, Item K400

Yellow or tan spaceman. Vintage 1960s, Stanley Home Products, 5".
$15.00, Item K386

Yellow or tan hobby horse. Vintage 1960s, Stanley Home Products, 3" tall.
Item K387

SOLD.

Yellow or tan Santa Head. Vintage 1960s, Stanley Home Products, 4".
Item K388

SOLD.

Yellow or tan Drum. Vintage 1960s, Stanley Home Products, 4".
Item K389

SOLD.

Yellow or tan snowman. Vintage 1960s, Stanley Home Products, 5".
Item K385

SOLD.

Yellow or tan angel. Vintage 1960s, Stanley Home Products, 5½".
Item K396

SOLD.

6 Nested heart cookie cutters. Sizes include 4 1/4", 3 3/4", 3 1/8", 2 1/2", 2", 1 1/8". Wilton enterprises, Woodridge IL 60517, Hong Kong 2105-5225. (3 in stock.)
$10.00, Item K15

2 nesting Red Heart Cookie Cutters. Largest is 4" across. Made in China.
$6.00, K298

Pink heart with arrow, 5" wide. 1985 Hallmark Cards. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K105

Pink Heart, The Enesco Precious Moments Collectors' Club, You & Me, 4" tall.
$8.00, K366

Green heart with arrow, 4" wide.
$3.00, Item K164

Green heart, 3" wide.
Item K163
SOLD.

Red Wilton Heart. 1992 Wilton enterprises, Woodridge IL 60517, Hong Kong 2303-0100. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K109

Red heart, Wilton, 1993, Taiwan, 3¾" wide.
Item K69

SOLD.

Red heart with smaller inner heart, Wilton, 1993. 3¾" wide.
$5.00, Item K70

Big Red Heart Cookie Cutter is 4" across. (4 in stock.)
$6.00, K226

Red Heart Cookie Cutter is 3" across.
$5.00, K390

Large red plastic decorated heart with center heart-shaped hole. Hallmark Cards, Inc.
K90

SOLD.

Small pink heart is 2" across. 1984, Hallmark Cards, Inc. Made in USA. (2 in stock.)
$4.00, K220

Teddy Bear is holding a heart that says Be Mine, 4¼". Has small handle. 1989, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, Taiwan, 2301-1214.
$8.00, K222

Red valentine hearts, 4". Has small handle. 1989, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, Taiwan, 2301-1214. (2 in stock.)
$8.00, K308

Red double hearts, 4½". Has small handle. 1989, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, Taiwan, 2301-1214.
$8.00, K320

Red scalloped I Love You heart, 4". Has small handle. 1989, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, Taiwan, 2301-1214.
$8.00, K310

Bright pink plastic, I Love You, 1997, Wilton, 2301-214, Taiwan, 4" wide.
Item K46

SOLD.

Big red lips cookie cutter. 1984 Hallmark Cards, Inc. 3" x 5".
$9.00, Item K20

Big green lips cookie cutter. 3¾" across.
$6.00, Item K324

Big red lips cookie cutter. 3¾" across.
$6.00, Item K311

Cookout set of 4 pink cookie cutters including hamburger, hotdog, fries, and ice cream cone. Handle imprinting: 1990 Wilton, Wooldridge, IL 60517, 2304-1515, Taiwan. 2"-4" tall.
SOLD.

Easter Babies set of 3 lavender cookie cutters including bunny rabbit with egg, lamb, and hatching chick. Imprinted with Made In China. About 3" tall.
$10.00, Item K18

SOLD.

Easter set of 3 pink cookie cutters including Easter basket, bunny rabbit, and chick. Imprinted with Made In China. About 3½" tall.
Item K19

SOLD.

Pink bunny cookie cutter. Imprinted with Made In China. 4" tall.
$4.00, Item K394

3" pink Easter egg.
$5.00, K257

3" lavender Easter egg. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, K221

Bright pink Decorated Easter Egg, Wilton, 1997, 2301-330, Taiwan, 3" tall.
Item K49

SOLD.

Yellow Wilton Egg with hanger, 1992, 2303-0119, Taiwan, 4" tall. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K61

Yellow Wilton Egg without hanger, 1992, 2303-0119, Taiwan, 4" tall.
$5.00, Item K62

2 green nested eggs, largest is 4½" tall. 1990, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, 2304-1519, Taiwan.
Item K299

SOLD.

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Hard red plastic Bunny Rabbit With Long Ears, 5" tall. Has a small handle on back.
$4.00, Item K144. (14 in stock.)

Puzzle Bunny Rabbit Cookie Cutters. Three cookie cutters in the set, still sealed in the original package. Easter Unlimited, Inc., Item #3302, Carle Place, NY 11514.
Item K102.

SOLD.

Set of 4 lavender Easter cookie cutters. Each is 3", tulip, chick in egg, standing lamb, and bunny rabbit.
$12.00, K266

Set of 4 pink Easter cookie cutters. Each is 3", tulip, chick in egg, standing lamb, and bunny rabbit.
$12.00, K262

Set of 3 yellow Easter cookie cutters. Each is about 4". Includes bunny rabbit, lamb, and decorated Easter egg. This set originally had a duck, but it is missing.
K3699
SOLD.

Set of 4 yellow Easter cookie cutters. Each is about 4". Includes bunny rabbit, lamb, duck, and decorated Easter egg.
K265
SOLD.

4" kneeling green lamb. 1990 Wilson, Woodridge, IL 60517, 2304-1519, Taiwan.
$4.00, K256

4" green bunny rabbit. 1990 Wilson, Woodridge, IL 60517, 2304-1519, Taiwan.
K235

SOLD.

4" green duck. 1990 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, 2304-1519, Taiwan.
K236

SOLD.

C&H White bunny rabbit with molded handle, Easter. 3½" wide.
$6.00, Item K146.

C&H White lamb with molded handle. 4" wide, Easter.
$6.00, Item K143.

C&H White butterfly with molded handle, Easter. 4" wide.
Item K142.

SOLD.

Yellow standing bunny rabbit cookie cutter with clothes on, 1997, Wilton, 2301-330, Taiwan, 3¾" tall. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K47

Yellow bunny rabbit face with bow tie. Hard yellow plastic. 1975, Hallmark Cards, 4¾" tall.
Item K119

SOLD.

Red HRM bunny rabbit face, 4" tall. Has HRM crown, marked: Made in U.S.A.
$12.00, Item K183

Red HRM hopping bunny rabbit, 4" tall. Has HRM crown, marked: Made in U.S.A.
Item K341

SOLD.

Red HRM Easter cross with lily, 4" tall. Has HRM crown, marked: Made in U.S.A.
$12.00, Item K181

Small red gingerbread man and woman, 3½" tall.
Item K300

SOLD.

Small Brown Gingerbread Man, Hallmark Cards, 2½" tall.
Item K112

SOLD.

Orange Gingerbread Man, Hallmark Cards, 5" tall.
Item K110

SOLD.

Red Tupperware Gingerbread Man, 4" tall. (2 in stock.)
$10.00, Item K140

Red Amscan Gingerbread Man, 3¾" tall.
Item K149

SOLD.

4" Blue Opaque Gingerbread Man cookie cutter. Imprinting says: Betty Crocker Gingerbread Mix, Made in U.S.A. There are two holes so the cookie will release easier. Has a small handle.
$15.00, Item K39

4" Red Transparent Gingerbread Man cookie cutter. Imprinting says: Betty Crocker Gingerbread Mix, Made in U.S.A. There are two holes so the cookie will release easier. Has a small handle. (2 in stock.)
$15.00, Item K40

This cutter is the same as K40 (above), but he has a damaged foot, with a bit of the cutter surface missing. 4" Red Transparent Gingerbread Man cookie cutter. Imprinting says: Betty Crocker Gingerbread Mix, Made in U.S.A. There are two holes so the cookie will release easier. Has a small handle.
$5.00, Item K40a

3½" white Hasbro gingerbread man. Marked: 1976 Hasbro Ind. Inc. 2 143189.
K357

SOLD.

3" white gingerbread man.
$5.00, K355

Large Yellow Wilton Boy, 1989, 509-91225, Taiwan, Gingerbread Boy.
Item K59

SOLD.

orange Little Dutch Girl With Apron Cookie Cutter, bright pink. Hallmark Cards, Inc., Kansas City, Missouri 64141. 5" tall. Photo shows this as pink, but it's bright orange.
K398

SOLD.

Little Dutch Girl With Apron Cookie Cutter, bright pink. Hallmark Cards, Inc., Kansas City, Missouri 64141. 5" tall.
K38

SOLD.

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Hard red plastic Dutch Boy, 4¾" tall. Has a small handle on back.
$4.00, Item K100. (18 in stock.)

Wilton Green Holly, 4½" tall.
$5.00, Item K118

Red HRM Holly Leaves. Marked: Made in USA, has crown.
Item K365

SOLD.

Red HRM Holly Leaves. Marked: Made in Hongkong.
$8.00, Item K395

Large Wilton Green Holly, 5½". 1988, Woodridge, IL 60517, 509-1222, Taiwan.
Item K306

SOLD.

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Hard red plastic Christmas tree, 4½" tall. Has a small handle on back. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K101.

Red HRM Christmas tree. Marked: Made in USA, has crown.
Item K333A

SOLD.

Red HRM Christmas tree. Marked: Made in China.
Item K333

SOLD.

Red HRM Christmas tree. Marked: Made in Hongkong.
$6.00, Item K333B

Green Christmas tree. Marked: Acme International Tree.
$8.00, Item K335

Small Red Christmas tree, 3". (3 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K297

Red Christmas tree, 4". (2 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K345

Small Green Christmas tree, 2½".
$3.00, Item K346

Small Green Christmas tree, 3". (2 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K346

1973 Large Red Christmas tree cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4½" tall.
Item K1

SOLD.

1973 Small Red Christmas Tree cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 2" tall.
$4.00, Item K127

1973 Small Green Christmas Tree cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 2" tall.
$4.00, Item K131

1973 Small Green Christmas Tree cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 2" tall. (2 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K103

1973 Large Green Christmas Tree cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4½" tall. (2 in stock.)
$12.00, Item K29

Small Red Christmas Tree cookie cutter, 3" tall, Hutzler, or like Hutzler. (5 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K78

Small Green Christmas Tree cookie cutter, 3" tall. Marked Hutzler, Set 62 - Set 63, Made in U.S.A.
$5.00, Item K155

Small Green Christmas Tree cookie cutter, 3" tall, like Hutzler, made in China. (2 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K155A

Small Green Christmas Tree cookie cutter, 3" tall, like Hutzler, no markings. (3 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K155B

Large Red Christmas Tree cookie cutter, 1978, Wilton, 3205-3214, Hong Kong. (2 in stock)
$10.00, Item K56

Green Wilton Christmas Tree, 1992, 2303-0132, 4" excluding hanger.
$5.00, Item K54

Green Wilton Christmas Tree, 1993, Taiwan, 4" excluding hanger. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K55

Red Christmas Tree, L.T.T.C., Pat Pend, 1978. 3" tall. (5 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K148

Red Christmas tree, 4¼". Holiday Cookie Cutters, Amscan. (3 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K150.

Large White Angel. 5" tall. (2 in stock.)
Item K141

SOLD.

3" Red HRM angel. Marked: Made in USA, has crown.
Item K339A

SOLD.

3" Red HRM angel. Marked: Made in Hong Kong. (3 in stock.)
$8.00, Item K339

3" green translucent angel.
$4.00, Item K178

1973 Green Angel With Halo cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4½" tall.
$12.00, Item K2

1979 Blue Angel cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4" tall.
$8.00, Item K10

Green Angel Cookie Cutter. Like Hutzler, Made In U.S.A. 3" tall. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K32

Green Angel Cookie Cutter. Like Hutzler, no markings. 3" tall.
$5.00, Item K32a

Small red plastic angel, marked Hutzler, 1986, Sets 62-63-68, made in U.S.A., 3".
$5.00, Item K391

Small red plastic angel, like Hutzler, made in China, 3". (8 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K80

Red large sweet angel, 5" tall, 1978 Wilton, 3205-1043, Hong Kong.
$15.00, Item K71

Small Red Angel press, 1½" round.
$2.00, Item K158.

Green Gabriel's horn with bow on top, 4"
Item K177

SOLD.

Red wrapped gift, 4½", 1978, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60515, Hong Kong, 509-3233.
Item K322.

SOLD.

Small Red Translucent Snowman Cookie Cutter. 3¼" tall.
Item K189

SOLD.

1973 Green Standing Snowman cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4¼" tall. This item shows wear around edges.
Item K3

SOLD.

White Snowman Cookie Cutter, Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4½"
Item K35

SOLD.

White Snowman With Bird Cookie Cutter, unmarked, Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4".
Item K364

SOLD.

Small White Snowman, Hallmark Cards, 2½" tall.
Item K132

SOLD.

Purple Snowman with brrom. Made In U.S.A. 3" tall.
Item K34

SOLD.

Small red standing snowman with broom, Hutzler. 3" tall, made in China. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K82

Small red standing snowman with broom, like Hutzler. 3" tall, made in China. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K82a

White Wilton Snowman with hat. 1993, Taiwan, 3½" tall. Doesn't have the hanger. (4 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K45

Red snowman child with stocking hat, 1992, Wilton, 2304-801, China, 3¾" tall.
Item K65

SOLD.

Red Snowman with hat and broom. L.T.T.C., Pat Pend., 1978, 4" tall. (4 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K77

Small red snowman head with hat, 2" tall. Hallmark Cards.
Item K107

SOLD.

Green Wilton Snowman, 1988, Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, Taiwan, 509-1224, 5½" tall.
Item K305

SOLD.

Small red snowman, 3½" tall. (3 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K302

Small white snowman, 2½" tall.
Item K354

SOLD.

Small green Santa head with hat, 2" tall. Hallmark Cards.
Item K108

SOLD.

Small Red Translucent Standing Santa Cookie Cutter. 3¼" tall.
$5.00, Item K188

1973 Red Big Smile Santa Standing cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4¼" tall.
Item K4

SOLD.

1973 Green Big Smile Santa Standing cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 4¼" tall.
Item K30

SOLD.

Green Standing Santa Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, Made In U.S.A. 3½" tall. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K37

Red Standing Santa Cookie Cutter. Marked Hutzler 1986, Sets 62-63-68, Made In U.S.A. 3¼" tall. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K393

Red Standing Santa Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, Made In U.S.A. 3¼" tall. (5 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K87

Red Standing Santa Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, Made In China. 3¼" tall. (3 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K367

Red Standing Santa Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, no markings. 3¼" tall. (3 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K367a

Small Green Santa Head, like Hutzler, made in China, 3¼".
Item K75

SOLD.

Small Green Santa Head, Hutzler, made in Hong Kong, 3¼".
Item K75A

SOLD.

Small Green Santa Head, like Hutzler, no markings, 3¼".
Item K75B

SOLD.

Small Red Santa Face, HRM, made in USA, has crown. 3¼".
Item K313A

SOLD.

Small Red Santa Face, HRM, made in Honk Kong, 3¼".
Item K313

SOLD.

Large Red Standing Santa with toy bag, 1978, Wilton, 3205-1038, Hong Kong, 4½" tall.
Item K74

SOLD.

Large Red Santa Face, 1978, L.T.T.C, Pat Pend. 4½" tall. (4 in stock.)
$8.00, Item K147

Red Wilton Standing Santa, 1978, Woodridge, IL 60515, Hong Kong, 509-3225, 4¾" tall.
Item K319

SOLD.

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Hard red plastic standing Santa Claus, 5" tall. Has a small handle on back.
$4.00, Item K99. (7 in stock.)

Red Santa, Amscan. 4" tall. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K139.

Red Santa Face, 5½" tall. Hallmark Cards, Inc.
Item K321.

SOLD.

Small Red Santa Face, 2½" tall. 1994 Wilton 2301-1038.
$4.00, Item K331.

Small Red Santa Face, 2½" tall. 1994 Wilton 2301-1038. This is the same as K331, but it still has the Wilton tag attached at the top.
$5.00, Item K331A.

Small Red Santa Face, 3" tall. (3 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K301.

Large Red Old World Santa, 5¼" tall. (2 in stock.)
$8.00, Item K161

Red Old World Santa, 4" tall. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K369

Red Disney Santa on sled, A Burly Bear dressed in Santa attire heads down the slopes on a sled. 2304-3001, Taiwan, 1996, Wilton, 4½" tall.
Item K309

SOLD.

Red Wilton stocking with toys, 1978, Woodridge, IL 60515, Hong Kong, 509-3268, 4¾" tall.
Item K318

SOLD.

Large Yellow Wilton Santa Boot, 1989, 509-91225, Taiwan, 4½" tall.
$5.00, Item K60

Small red Santa boot, 3" tall. (3 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K347

Small Green Hallmark Stocking, 2½" tall.
Item K104

SOLD.

Tiny Green Hallmark Stocking, 2" tall.
Item K113

SOLD.

Green Dove cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Hallmark Cards, Inc. 2¼" tall. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K8

Red HRM drum, 2¾". Has the HRM crown and marked: made in U.S.A.
Item K332

SOLD.

Red HRM Christmas Tree Ornament, 3¼". Marked: made in Hong Kong.
$8.00, Item K338

Red HRM Christmas Tree Ornament, 3¼". Marked: made in U.S.A., has crown.
$8.00, Item K338A

Green Christmas Tree Ornament, similar to Hunzler, 3" tall, made in China. (3 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K76

Red Joy Christmas Tree Ornament, 3" tall, Hallmark Cards.
Item K128

SOLD.

Orange Wilton Crinkle Square, 3½" tall.
Item K63

SOLD.

Purple Wilton Crinkle Circle, 3" tall. 1991
Item K115

SOLD.

Blue Wilton Six Point Star, 1992, 2303-0122, Taiwan, 4".
Item K67

SOLD.

Red star, 3". Holiday Cookie Cutters, Amscan.
$5.00, Item K329 (2 in stock.)

Red 6-pointed star, 2½".
Item K330

SOLD.

Green Wilton Five Point Star, 1992, 2303-0135, Taiwan, 4".
$5.00, Item K111

Green Wilton Star, 1992, 2303-0135, Taiwan, 4".
$5.00, Item K51

White Wilton Star, 3½" tall. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K68

4 yellow nested star cookie cutters range from 2 to 4". Wilton Enterprises, Inc., Woodridge, IL 60517, Hong Kong,2105-5209.
Item K289

SOLD.

Red Star, L.T.T.C, Pat Pend, 1978, 2¾" tall. (4 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K154

5-pointed red star has starburst design and is textured. 4" across, with two small handles. This is an oldie.
$16.00, K219

Light Green Star Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, Made In U.S.A. 2¼" tall.
$5.00, Item K33

Dark Green Star Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, Made In China. 2¼" tall. (7 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K85

Dark Green Star Cookie Cutter. Similar to Hutzler, no markings. 2¼" tall.
$4.00, Item K85a

4" white star.
K350

SOLD.

Yellow Flower. Sticker says Daisy. 4" diameter.
Item K21

SOLD.

Yellow Wilton Flower, 1992, 2303-0117, Taiwan, 4". This one doesn't have the hanger attached. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K58

Green Wilton Wreath, 1993, Taiwan, 3¼" tall.
$5.00, Item K52

Green Wilton Wreath, 1993, Taiwan, 3¼" tall. This one has no hanger at the top. (4 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K52a

White shaper, 2"-2½". (2 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K171

Red Decorated Wreath, 1978 Wilton, 3205-3125, Hong Kong.
Item K53

SOLD.

Red HRM bells with bow. Marked: Made in Hong Kong. 3½" across.
$8.00, Item K187

Red HRM bells with bow. Marked: Has a crown, Made in USA. 3½" across.
$8.00, Item K187A

Set of 2 red cookie cutters. 2" bell and star. Advertising on back of package says Ritz. Happy Holidays from your Friends at Ritz! Still in the original package. (3 in stock)
$4.00, Item K379

Small white bell, 2½" long.
$3.00, Item K356

Small red bell, 2¾" long.
$4.00, Item K303

Small Red Translucent Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter. 3" tall.
$5.00, Item K190

Small Green Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter, Hutzler. Made In U.S.A. 3" tall. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K36

Small Dark Green Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter. Like Hutzler, made In China. 3" tall. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K36a

Small Red Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter, Hutzler, made in U.S.A., 3" tall.
$4.00, Item K392

Small Red Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter, Hutzler, made in China, 3" tall. (3 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K81

Small Red Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter, like Hutzler, 3" tall. (4 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K81a

Small Red Bell with Bow Cookie Cutter, like Hutzler, no markings, 3" tall.
$4.00, Item K81b

White Wilton Bell, 1993, Taiwan, 3½" tall.
$5.00, Item K66

Red Bell, L.T.T.C, Pat Pend, 1978, 3" tall. (3 in stock.)
Item K153

SOLD.

Green Wilton Teddy Bear, 1993, 2303-0133, U.S.A., 4".
$5.00, Item K44

Red Wilton Teddy Bear, 1993, Taiwan, 4". (4 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K57

Red Wilton Teddy Bear, 1993, Taiwan, 4". Has no hanger.
$5.00, Item K57a

Red Teddy Bear, 3½"tall. (7 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K160

Red Teddy Bear, similar to Hunzler, 3" tall. (12 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K83

Green Teddy Bear, 3" tall.
Item K162

SOLD.

Large Red Teddy Bear, almost 5" tall.
$8.00, Item K159

Huge Green Wilton Teddy Bear is 9" tall. Marked Wilton Teddy Bear., 1992, Woodridge, IL 60517, 2303-0098, Hong Kong.
$8.00, K288

4 pink nested teddy bear cookie cutters range from 1½" - 6½" tall. Marked Taiwan.
$8.00, K287

Translucent, red plastic HRM lamb. Marked Pat. Pend. 4".
Item K182

SOLD.

5½" green candy cane.
Item K323

SOLD.

Translucent, red plastic HRM candy cane. Made in USA with Crown. 4" tall.
Item K184

SOLD.

Translucent, red plastic HRM candy cane, unmarked. 4" tall.
Item K184A

SOLD.

4½" candy cane. Holiday Cookie Cutters, Amscan.
$5.00, Item K325

Large Red Wilton Candy Cane, 5½" tall.
Item K122

SOLD.

Red Candy Cane cookie cutter, Hallmark Cards, Inc., 3¼" tall.
Item K48

SOLD.

Red Candy Cane in square, 4" tall. (5 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K88

Red hard plastic candy cane with bow, 5". 1978 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60515, Hong Kong, 509-3209.
Item K344

SOLD.

Small Red Horse, similar to Hunzler, 3¼" tall.
Item K79

SOLD.

4" White horse.
$5.00, Item K351

Green Wilton Rudolph head, 1988, Woodridge, IL 60517, 509-1223, Taiwan, 5½" tall.
Item K307

SOLD.

Green Wilton Reindeer, 1993, Taiwan, 4" tall (with hanger).
Item K64

SOLD.

Green Wilton Reindeer, 1993, Taiwan, 4" tall (without hanger).
$5.00, Item K64

Yellow Wilton Reindeer, 1989, 509-91225, Taiwan, 5" tall.
Item K50

SOLD.

Red hard plastic reindeer, 3" wide. (4 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K156

Red hard plastic reindeer, 5". 1978 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60515, Hong Kong, 509-3276.
Item K328

SOLD.

Green Tupperware Clover or Shamrock, 4½" tall, including stem. (2 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K72

Bright Green Tupperware Clover or Shamrock, 4½" tall, including stem. (6 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K336

Small Green Shamrock, 2" tall. (2 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K157

Green Train Engine, similar to Hunzler, 3¼" wide.
Item K84

SOLD.

Red Train Engine, similar to Hunzler, 3¼" wide. (3 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K381

1979 Painted Count Dracula Cookie Cutter, 4" tall. Hallmark Cards, Inc.
$16.00, Item K28

White Hallmark Skelaton Face. 4¼" tall. Halloween. Hallmark Cards, Inc. (3 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K383

White Wilton Ghost, 1991, 509-1030, Taiwan, 4¼" tall. Halloween. (4 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K73

5½" orange Wilton ghost standing behind a tombstone that says R.I.P. 1987 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, China, 2304-242. (3 in stock.)
$8.00, Item K316

White Ghost BOO, Hallmark Cards, 4" wide. Halloween.
Item K86

SOLD.

White Ghost, Hallmark Cards, 3" tall. Halloween. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K121

Orange Ghost, Hallmark Cards, 3" tall. Halloween.
$5.00, Item K130

Purple ghost, 4". (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K175

Transparent, hard plastic, Orange Amscan Ghost, 3½" tall. Halloween.
$5.00, Item K152

Transparent, hard plastic, Orange Amscan Cat With Arched Back, 3" tall. Halloween.
$5.00, Item K151

Set of two giant 5¾" cookie cutters. Black pumpkin and orange bat.The Ulman Company, Inc., Item #205303. Still in its original package.
$10.00, K377

Set of 4 orange Halloween cookie cutters are about 4" each. Bat, pumpkin, sitch, and cat. (2 in stock.)
$10.00, K291

Orange Witch, Hallmark Cards (unmarked), 4" tall. Halloween.
$6.00, Item K125

5½" orange Wilton cat on a fence with a big round moon in the bakground. 1987 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, China, 2304-240. (3 in stock.)
$8.00, Item K315

5½" orange Wilton Witch flying on her broom in front of a big round moon. 1987 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, China, 2304-240. (3 in stock.)
$8.00, Item K317

Orange Witch Head, Hallmark Cards, 4" tall. Halloween.
Item K126

SOLD.

Orange Flying Witch, Hallmark Cards, 3" tall. Halloween. (3 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K129

Black Witch, Hallmark Cards, 4" tall. Halloween. (3 in stock.)
$7.00, Item K134

Black bat, 4½" across, 1991, Wilton, 509-1030, Taiwan. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K223

Black cat, 4½" tall, 1991, Wilton, 509-1030, Taiwan. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K225

Black witch face, 4½" tall, 1991, Wilton, 509-1030, Taiwan.
$6.00, Item K224

Purple man in the moon, 4". (2 in stock.)
$6.00, Item K174

3¾" gold owl, 1980, Hallmark Cards, Inc.
Item K304

SOLD.

Orange Owl, Hallmark Cards, 3½" tall. Halloween.
Item K106

SOLD.

Orange Cat Face, Hallmark Cards, 3¼" tall. Halloween.
Item K124

SOLD.

Orange Cat, Hallmark Cards, 3" tall. Halloween.
Item K123

SOLD.

Red Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin, 4" wide. Halloween.
Item K89

SOLD.

Purple pumpkin, 4" across.
$6.00, Item K176

5" orange Wilton pumpkin jack-o-lantern. 1987 Wilton, Woodridge, IL 60517, China, 2304-243.
Item K314

SOLD.

Orange Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin, 3" wide. Halloween. Hallmark Cards.
Item K114

SOLD.

Orange Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin, 4" wide. Halloween. Hallmark Cards.
Item K120

SOLD.

4" orange Pumpkin, Wilton, 1991, 509-1030, Taiwan. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, K237

4" Pumpkin, marked Splenda, unused.
K258

SOLD.

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Hard red plastic Jack-O-Lantern, ½" wide. Has a small handle on back. (10 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K97

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Red Happy Birthday Cake, 4¼" wide. Has a small handle on back. (17 in stock.)
$3.00, Item K91

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Red Thanksgiving Turkey, 3½" wide. Has a small handle on back. (4 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K92

1970s Tupperware, plastic. Shy Little Pig, Red Standing Pig, 4¾" tall. Has a small handle on back. (13 in stock.)
$4.00, Item K93

Blue Wilton Fish, 1993, 2303-0128, U.S.A., 3¾" wide.
$5.00, Item K94

Blue Wilton Duck, 1993, 2303-0148, U.S.A., 3¾" wide. (2 in stock.)
$5.00, Item K116

Pink Wilton Goose, 1988, 2304-432, 4" at tallest point.
$5.00, Item K117

Brown Hallmark football, 4½" long.
$6.00, Item K137.

Gray Football Cookie Cutter with a star is 5¾" wide. It is unmarked, but had to be made with the Dallas Cowboys in mind.
Item K214.

SOLD.

Black Congrats, for the graduate, has scroll and graduation cap. 1995 Wilton, 2304-1800. 3½" wide.
Item K133.

SOLD.

Black Great Grad!. 1995 Wilton, 2304-1800. 3" wide.
Item K135.

SOLD.

Black Diploma. 1995 Wilton, 2304-1800. 2½" wide.
Item K136.

SOLD.

Set of 3 Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats shapers. Recipe on the back for original Rice Krispies Treats. Includes polar bear, seal, and penguin. Unused, sealed in the original package.
$10.00, Item K165.

Set of 5 transparent Christmas cookie cutters. Each of these cutters has a tab attached. Star, Santa, Sleigh, Reindeer, and Angel. Santa is 3½" tall.
K173

SOLD.

DynoBytes. Blue double dinosaur sandwich cutter, removes crust and shapes bread. Hard plastic, 4". Can be used as a cookie cutter. (2 in stock.)
$8.00, K180

White Good Morning bread or toast shaper.
Item K145.

SOLD.

3 red plastic nesting ruffled circles. 2", 2½", and 3".
K186

SOLD.

Red Translucent Soldier Cookie Cutter. 3½" tall.
Item K185

SOLD.

Painted Train, White with red, green, and gold accents, is 3½" across. Unmarked, like Hallmark.
$14.00, K209

Painted Teddy Bear, White with red, green, and gold accents, is 3" tall. Unmarked, like Hallmark. (2 in stock.)
$14.00, K208

Set of 3 Bears cookie cutters, 1998, Hutzler, No. 661. Papa Bear, Mama Bear, and Baby Bear. Made in USA. Papa Bear is 3" tall. Still in its original package.
$15.00, Item K376

4½" orange elephant cookie cutter, 1984. Wilton Cookie Maker, Stock No. 2304-132. Still in its original package.
$8.00, Item K373

Lavender Puppy With Ball, 4", handle, 1990 Wilton, Wooldridge, IL 60517, 2304-1505, China.
K249

SOLD.

Lavender Puppy With Bone, 4", handle, 1990 Wilton, Wooldridge, IL 60517, 2304-1505, China.
K250

SOLD.

Lavender Puppy With Bowl, 4", handle, 1990 Wilton, Wooldridge, IL 60517, 2304-1505, China.
K251

SOLD.

Lavender Puppy Sitting, 4", handle, 1990 Wilton, Wooldridge, IL 60517, 2304-1505, China.
K259

SOLD.

Set of 4 Lavender Puppies: sitting, with ball, bone, and bowl. Each is 4", and has a handle handle, 1990 Wilton, Wooldridge, IL 60517, 2304-1505, China.
K261
SOLD.

4" purple Barney the dinosaur. Has small handle. 1993, The Lyons Group, Wilton, Woodbridge, IL, 2304-9420. (2 in stock.)
$6.00, K243

3" purple Barney face, the dinosaur. Has small handle. 1993, The Lyons Group, Wilton, Woodbridge, IL, 2304-9420.
K244

SOLD.

3½" purple Baby Bop, the dinosaur. Has small handle. 1993, The Lyons Group, Wilton, Woodbridge, IL, 2304-9420.
K245

SOLD.

4", orange dog Odie, Garfield's buddy. 1978, 1983, United Feature Syndicate, Inc. Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60507, 2304-1501, Taiwan.
K239

SOLD.

4", orange sitting Garfield. 1978, 1983, United Feature Syndicate, Inc. Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60507, 2304-1501, Taiwan.
K242

SOLD.

4", orange sleeping Garfield. 1978, 1983, United Feature Syndicate, Inc. Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60507, 2304-1501, Taiwan.
K240

SOLD.

4", orange Garfield face. 1978, 1983, United Feature Syndicate, Inc. Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60507, 2304-1501, Taiwan.
K241

SOLD.

Set of 4 Garfield cookie cutters. Includes Garfield's face, sleeping Garfield, Sitting Garfield, and Odie, Garfield's dog. 1978, 1983, United Feature Syndicate, Inc. Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60517, 2304-1501, Taiwan.
K263
SOLD.

4½" Green Gingerbread House, with small handle. 1988, Wilton, woodridge, IL 60517, 509-1221, Taiwan.
K238

SOLD.

Set of 4 Yellow Baby Shower Cookie Cutters. Each is about 4". Includes rattle, bottle, bootie, and teddy bear. 1991, Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60517, 2304-1522, China. SOLD.
K264

Orange Tupperware nested shapers fit together for storage and make scallops, stars, and hearts. 4" across.
K285

SOLD.

Orange Tupperware shapers. 730-5. 2½" across. (2 in stock.)
$4.00, K327

Red Tupperware shapers. 730-9. 2½" across.
$4.00, K368. (2 in stock.)

3½" Lowly Worm. Apple with a worm in it, 1977, Richard Scarry, Hallmark Cards.
K340

SOLD.

4" white Snoopy head.
K353

SOLD.

4¼" red American Flag. (2 in stock.)
$8.00, K337

Set of 7 animal shapers, each approximately 2¾". Bird, pig, cat, goat, 2 dogs, bunny rabbit. (I think!)
$10.00, K294

Set of 6 small shapers including heart, 2 starbursts, hippo, teddy bear, and elephant. Each is about 2¼".
$8.00, K295

Brown turkey cookie cutter. Hallmark Cards, Inc. 3". (2 in stock.)
$8.00, K382

Orange turkey cookie cutter. Hallmark Cards, Inc. 3".
K382a

SOLD.

Brown turkey cookie cutter. GGI. 3¼" across.
K312

SOLD.

Orange turkey cookie cutter. 4" tall. (2 in stock.)
$7.00, K384

Green translucent dancing clown, 4".
K334

SOLD.

Yellow seal balancing a ball on its nose. 2½"
K169

SOLD.

White Candle, 3½" tall.
K170

SOLD.

Yellow ice cream cone shaper, 3½".
$5.00, K168

Small yellow bunny rabbit shaper, 2½"
$6.00, K166

Small yellow leaf shaper, 2½".
K167

SOLD.

Set of six Mighty Morphin Power Rangers. I don't know if these are cookie cutters, Play-do shapers, or just what they are. 1994 8ABAN. Each cutter is about 3" x 5½".
$25.00, K360

8" tall, red cookie cutter. Snoopy sleeping on top of his doghouse. United Feature Syndicate, Inc.
K292

SOLD.

1970s The Bobbs Merrill Co., Inc. Hard red and blue plastic Raggedy Ann and Raggedy Andy, the pair. Each is 4½" tall and has a small handle on back.
$15.00, Item K96.

1978, Warner Bros, Inc. Hard red plastic. Tweety 509-3055; Porky Pig 509-3012; Buggs Bunny 509-3053; and Sylvester 509-3039. Each is 3½" to 4½" tall and has a small handle on back. Set of 4.
Item K98.

SOLD.

The whole set in great condition. The Twelve Days Of Christmas. 1978, A.S.C. Chilton Aluminum Specialty Company, Manitowoc, Wis, USA 54220. Hard red plastic. Each has a small handle on back. Does not include original box. Set of 12. Christmas.
Item K95.

SOLD.

Jumbo Numbers Cookie Cutter Set of 9. The number 9 is also used as the 6. 4" tall. Hallmark Cards, Inc. Ambassador Numbers, 1978. SOLD.
Item K27

Set Of 4 Disney Cookie Cutters, about 3". Mickey, Minnie, Donald Duck, and Pluto. Still in original package.
SOLD.
K41

Six extra large Disney characters to make holiday cookies. About 3".
SOLD.
K42

Set of 4 Disney characters cookie cutters including Winnie The Pooh, Piglet, Tigger, and Eeyore. Imprinted with Disney. Tigger is almost 5" tall.
Item K31

SOLD.

Blue Mickey Mouse cookie cutter. Handle imprinting: Disney 2303-360, Wilton, Taiwan. 3½" tall.
Item K9

SOLD.

Rolling Cookie Cutter with 18 interchangeable cutter shapes. Fit 6 of them on the wheel and roll over the dough. Gently used, still in the box. Gingerbread girl, angel, bell, tree, house, gingerbread boy, snowman, reindeer, heart, 4-leaf clover, flower, 6 point star, cross, scalloped circle, star, shining star & diamond.
$10.00, K370

Holiday Cookie Cutters, Amscan. Five cookie shapers including gingerbread man, star, standing Santa, Christmas tree, and candy cane. In unopened package. Christmas.
Item K17

SOLD.

7 Yellow Muppets Transportation Cookie Cutters, Sesame Street. ©Jim Henson Publications, Inc., Wilton, Woodbridge, IL 60617. 2304-116/118/119, Hong Kong. Grouch as an astronaut BLASTOFF, Ernie in an airplane, Bert in a car, Elmo in a rowboat, Big Bird on a bicycle, clown in a firetruck, and Cookie Monster in a train. Each about 3½" wide.
Item K43

SOLD.

Go to METAL COOKIE CUTTERS

SHOPPING DIRECTORY | SHOPPING CART

Site Map
General Information
Home

Order & Payment Info
Links & Link Exchange
Contact Us